APPENDIX C: Brainstorming Rating Scale Results Methods for Identifying Medication Use
Practicality
Method
All Experts
Physicians & Pharmacologists
Driving Evaluators
Behavioral Researchers
Database Experts
n
mean
sd
range
Sd
A
13
51.5
28.2
10-95
4
51.3
32.8
10-90
3
76.7
17.6
60-95
23.33
12.6
10-35
55.0
22.9
35-80
B
12
75.8
14.8
50-95
76.3
13.8
60-90
2
65.0
21.2
50-80
90.0
5
85-95
68.3
55-80
C
64.8
18.0
35-90
66.7
23.6
40-85
15.3
29.3
57.3
4.6
52-60
D
77.7
18.6
30-95
67.5
26.3
30-90
16.1
65-95
81.7
88.3
11.6
75-95
E
35.7
22.8
5-79
33.8
29.6
5-70
31.7
15-50
26.7
15-45
27.0
25-79
F
70.4
20-95
14.4
55-85
71.7
20.8
55-95
63.3
37.9
20-90
18.9
55-90
G
10
59.1
18.4
58.3
28.4
17.7
47.5
10.6
40-55
62.0
16.6
50-81
B + G
1
80
--
0
B + C + G
70
Reliability
61.7
18.3
30-85
73.8
9.5
60-80
50-85
65.7
16.8
38.3
10.4
30-50
63.9
17.0
12.3
50-75
60.0
17.3
56.7
30-75
73.3
20.2
81.5
6.9
70-90
83.8
75.0
5.0
70-80
83.3
2.9
80-85
5.8
80-90
69.2
50-90
71.3
15.5
60-70
66.3
16.0
50-82
5.6
92.5
90-95
90-90
91.7
2.89
85.0
10.0
55.1
20-75
13.2
15.2
35-65
47.3
23.7
20-62
7.6
50-65
11
61.3
26.9
15-95
30.8
15-80
74.5
29.0
54-95
35.0
14.1
25-45
25.2
45-95
A +E
95
E + G
90
A + B + D
100
Cost-Effectiveness
64.5
26.8
5-95
53.7
33.5
5-80
91.0
5.3
45-65
24.1
25-90
37.5
48.3
22.6
25-70
59.6
70.0
51.7
7.64
45-60
21.8
35-75
28.9
40-90
78.7
35-95
81.3
4.8
75-85
74.3
34.1
40.0
22.4
38.8
19.3
10-50
46.7
35-70
25.0
15-40
50.0
36.1
78.5
19.7
30.7
70-95
62.5
17.5
68.8
21.0
57.5
24.8
40-75
Overall
54.5
19.0
10-75
53.8
10-70
45-75
6.4
44-55
65.3
17.1
20.4
24.7
14.0
52-80
75.3
13.3
45-85
7.5
70-85
82.3
77-85
12.5
57-80
73.1
12.8
72.5
8.7
45.0
74.7
12.9
60-84
66.4
23.2
30-97
22.2
30-80
80.7
65-97
78.3
52.0
32-80
55.9
25-81
7.1
40-65
41.7
20.1
25-65
68.7
11.0
60-81
51.2
20.7
20-80
30-45
62.3
47-80
75
C + D
A+ D + E
B + D + G
A + B + D + G
A + B + E + G