Medical Conditions and Driving: A Review of the Literature (1960 – 2000)
TRD Page
Foreword
Acknowledgements
Section1: Introduction
Section 2: Vision
Section 3: Hearing
Section 4: Cardiovascular
Section 5: Cerebrovascular
Section 6: Peripheral Vascular
Section 7: Nervous System
Section 8: Respiratory
Section 9: Metabolic
Section 10: Renal
Section 11: Musculoskeletal
Section 12: Psychiatric
Section 13: Drugs
Section 14: Aging Driver
Section 15: Anesthesia and Surgery
Appendix A
List of Tables
List of Figures
download PDF

Section 9: Metabolic Diseases

Hypoglycemia Unawareness

Hypoglycemic unawareness is commonly defined as an inability to recognize the autonomic symptoms (sweating, tremor, hunger, anxiety, and palpitations) of decreased plasma glucose concentrations or a failure of the warning signs to occur before development of neuroglycopenia (Gerich et al., 1991). In some European countries, unawareness of hypoglycemia is considered the most important reason for denying driving privileges to individuals with diabetes mellitus (Veneman, 1996). A review of the literature suggests that hypoglycemic unawareness is a frequent phenomenon among insulin treated diabetics. Table 27 provides a summary of those studies that have investigated the frequency of hypoglycemia unawareness in individuals with diabetes. Despite the varying methodologies (e.g., populations, categorization of hypoglycemic unawareness, retrospective versus prospective surveys, etc.), the best current estimate is that hypoglycemia unawareness occurs in about 25 percent of individuals with IDDM, with estimates ranging from eight percent to 70 percent. Bergada, Suissa, Dufresne, and Schiffrin (1989) report the highest rate (70 percent). However, their total study population consisted of 350 diabetic children and some of the episodes not preceded by warning symptoms occurred during the night. The higher rates (50 and 51 percent, respectively) reported by Arias, Kernerm Zier, Navacues, and Pfeiffer (1985) and the DCCT Research Group (1991) may be the result of therapeutic regime. In both investigations, the samples consisted of IDDM individuals undergoing intensive insulin therapy.

Table 27 Summary of Studies Investigating the Frequency of Hypoglycemia Unawareness

(Reproduced from Spinger-Verlag Diabetologica, Hypoglycemic reactions in 172 Type 1 [Insulin Dependent] diabetic patients, Gerich et al., 24, 95-99, 1991 with permission from Springer-Verlag)

Study

Subjects (n)

Unawareness (n)

Percent

Arias et al. (1985)

19

10

50

Bergada et al. (1989)

24

17

70

Berlin et al. (1987)

37

12

33

Collier et al. (1987)

49

12

25

Fui et al. (1986)

11

4

35

Goldgewicht et al. (1983)

180

36

20

Grimaldi et al. (1990)

151

26

17

Hepburn et al. (1990)

302

69

23

Mokan et al. (1991)

34

9

26

Moses et al. (1985)

52

6

12

Orchard et al. (1991)

628

126

20

Potter et al. (1982)

120

10

8

Pramming et al. (1991)

411

111

27

Ryder et al. (1990)

23

5

22

The DCCT Research Group (1991)

216

110

51

Overall Average

2257

563

25

 

Back

Top

Next