Interpretation ID: 3300yy

Mr. Terry Semprini
Executive Director
Cycle Country Accessories Corp.
Rt. 3, Box 125
Hwy 71 North
Milford, Iowa 51351

Dear Mr. Semprini:

This responds to your letter of December 10, 1991, to Taylor Vinson of this Office, asking whether a lighting device developed by your company "is legal to run in all of the United States."

From the pictures you enclosed, we note that your device is a diamond-shape lamp, incorporating six amber lamps which form right and left turn signals. In addition, four red lamps are used for stop and hazard warning lamp purposes. These lamps are arranged in a V shape at the top of the device, and an inverted V at the bottom. In the photos you enclosed, the device appears installed near the top of the truck, to the left of the vertical centerline, midway between the centerline and the left edge of the vehicle. It appears that the intent of this device is, in the position depicted, to serve as the vehicle's turn signal lamps, hazard warning signal lamps, and stop lamps in the event that the original equipment lamps were obscured by one or more intervening vehicles. This would occur were the stop lamps and turn signal lamps mounted at the bottom of the vehicle body, as depicted in your photographs.

By way of background information, Section 103 of the National Traffic and Motor Vehicle Safety Act (Safety Act; 15 U.S.C. 1392) authorizes the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) to issue Federal motor vehicle safety standards for new motor vehicles and new items of motor vehicle equipment. We have exercised this authority to establish Standard No. 108, Lamps, Reflective Devices, and Associated Equipment (49 CFR 571.108). Standard No. 108 applies to new motor vehicles and to lamps, reflective devices, and associated equipment for replacement of original equipment lamps, reflective devices, and associated equipment. As noted above, it appears that your company's lighting device would be offered as an aftermarket item to supplement, not replace, the original equipment lamps. Assuming this is the case, Standard No. 108 would not directly apply to your company's lighting device and your company would not be required to certify that the lighting device conforms with Standard No. 108.

Even though Standard No. 108 does not appear to directly apply to this lighting device, there is a provision of the Safety Act that applies to the installation of aftermarket items of motor vehicle equipment. Section 108(a)(2)(A) of the Safety Act (15 U.S.C. 1397(a)(2)(A)) prohibits any manufacturer, distributor, dealer, or repair shop from knowingly "rendering inoperative," in whole or in part, any device or element of design installed on or in a vehicle in compliance with an applicable safety standard. The effect of this provision is to make it unlawful for any of the named commercial establishments to add or replace any lamp, reflective device, or associated equipment on a motor vehicle if the commercial establishment knows or should know that the addition of the aftermarket lighting equipment results in the vehicle no longer complying with Standard No. 108.

It appears that your company's lighting device would "render inoperative" the required lighting equipment on a trailer by impairing its effectiveness.

First, we note that the device as positioned fails to fulfill basic locational requirements of Standard No. l08 that rear lamps be installed one on each side of the vertical centerline and as far apart as practicable. The signal sent by these lamps could therefore be perceived as conflicting or unclear when viewed simultaneously with the original equipment lamps.

Second, we note that the hazard warning system of the device operates through the stop lamps rather than through the turn signal system as is the case with original equipment. This means that a viewer could be faced with the necessity of interpreting the meaning of simultaneously flashing red and amber lamps on the rear of the vehicle, as well as the meaning of the original stop lamps should the brakes also be applied.

Finally, we note that the stop lamp portion of the device, two lamps forming a V and two more an inverted V, form a lighting array that the public does not associate as a traditional stop lamp system, usually circular or rectangular lamps. Thus, a viewer to the rear could be faced with a momentary delay in interpreting the meaning of the simultaneous appearance of light from the stop lamps, and from the auxiliary device mounted to the left of center on the rear of the vehicle.

For the above reasons, we view your device as having the potential to render inoperative certain rear lamps required on trailers by Standard No. 108. Accordingly, it would be a violation of Federal law for any manufacturer, distributor, dealer, or repair shop to install your company's lighting device on a customer's trailer.

This "render inoperative" prohibition does not apply to individual vehicle owners. Vehicle owners may add lighting devices or make other modifications to their own vehicles without violating any provision of Federal law, even if the owner's modifications result in the vehicle no longer complying with Standard No. 108. However, the individual States are free to establish whatever restrictions, if any, they deem appropriate on individual owner modifications. Thus, a State or States might choose to prohibit individual owners from equipping their trailers with your company's lighting device. We are unable to advise you on the laws of the individual States. You can obtain further information on State laws by writing to: American Association of Motor Vehicle Administrators, 4600 Wilson Boulevard, Arlington, Va. 22203.

Sincerely,

Paul Jackson Rice Chief Counsel

/ref:108#VSA d:1/23/92