Interpretation ID: aiam3783
President
Isis Imports
Ltd.
P.O. Box 2290
US Custom House
San Francisco
CA 94126;
CERTIFIED MAIL--RETURN RECEIPT REQUESTED Dear Mr. Fink: This is in response to your letter of October 21, 1983 requestin confidential treatment for information which was submitted to the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) with statements of compliance and which pertained to vehicles imported by Isis Imports, Ltd. into the United States. In telephone conversations with Heidi Lewis Coleman of my staff, you indicated that you had no object to the release of HS Forms 189. You requested, however, that submitted drawings, diagrams, specifications and photographs showing the methods and extent of modifications made to Morgan vehicles be treated confidentially by this agency. After carefully reviewing the submitted materials and your justifications I have decided to grant your request in part and deny it in part.; All submitted materials will be afforded confidential treatment wit the exception of the photographs. NHTSA does not believe that their release will cause substantial harm to Isis Imports. In order to determine whether release of information will cause such harm, courts consider 'how valuable the information will be to the requesting competitors and how much this gain will damage the submitter.' *Worthington Compressors, Inc. v. Costle*, 662 F. 2d 45, 51 (D.C. Cir. 1981).; You indicate that a presumption has been established by 49 CFR Part 51 with respect to blueprints and engineering drawings containing process of production data where the subject could not be manufactured without the blueprints or engineering drawings except after significant reverse engineering. This case determination, however, pertains only to blueprints and engineering drawings, it cannot be interpreted to apply to photographs. Additionally, release of the photographs will not be very valuable to the requesting competitor, and will therefore not cause substantial harm to Isis Imports. Since accompanying diagrams, text and other information will remain confidential, significant reverse engineering will still be required to determine the methods and extent of modifications necessary to bring Morgan vehicles into compliance with Federal standards.; If you wish to submit additional justification explaining why Isis i entitled to confidential treatment for the photographs you must do so within 10 days of your receipt of this letter. At the end of that period, they will be made publicly available. I will notify appropriate agency personnel of this decision, and they will treat your submissions accordingly.; Sincerely, Frank Berndt, Chief Counsel